Skip to main content

Big Mistakes Review

Written on .

Consensus Review 16 independent sources

Big Mistakes

A dark comedy-crime series created by Dan Levy that explores dysfunctional family dynamics through a chaotic, high-stakes lens.

6.4 /10
MIXED RECEPTION
✅ 62% Positive (10 sources) ⚠️ 25% Mixed (4 sources) ❌ 13% Negative (2 sources)

How This Score Is Calculated

  • Sources analysed: 16 reviews
  • Sentiment-only: All sources weighted 1.0×
  • Split: 10 Positive · 4 Mixed · 2 Negative
  • Raw weighted average: 6.4
  • Final score: 6.4/10
  • Most reviewed featureCast Performances (16/16)
  • Most praisedLead Chemistry
  • Most criticisedIllogical Plot
  • Reviewer consensus levelModerate
Mixed Reception Dark Comedy Fans Dan Levy Fans

Big Mistakes is a polarizing dark comedy that hinges entirely on the magnetic chemistry of its lead cast. While reviewers consistently praise the hilarious performances and sharp, cynical dialogue, the series struggles to maintain logical consistency in its crime-thriller subplots. It is a bingeable, chaotic experience that often prioritizes style and humor over a coherent narrative structure.

📊 What Reviewers Say — Feature by Feature

3 features evaluated across 16 sources.

✅
Cast Performances The ensemble cast, led by Dan Levy and featuring standout turns by Laurie Metcalf and Taylor Ortega, is universally cited as the show's greatest strength.
16 / 16
✅
Comedy & Dialogue Reviewers describe the writing as sharp, witty, and biting, effectively balancing domestic cringe comedy with dark, high-stakes tension.
12 / 16
❌
Plot & Logic The series is frequently criticized for relying on implausible coincidences, weak thriller elements, and a lack of internal narrative consistency.
11 / 16

👍 Key Strengths

  • Stellar, high-energy lead cast
  • Sharp, witty, and cynical dialogue
  • Engaging dysfunctional family dynamics
  • Fast-paced, bingeable execution

👎 Key Weaknesses

  • Illogical and implausible crime plot
  • Jarring shifts in tone
  • Underdeveloped supporting characters
  • Relentless, grating noise level

⚡ Where Reviewers Disagreed

The following areas saw meaningful disagreement across sources.

  • Pacing: 4 sources praised the frantic, fast-paced nature of the show, while 3 sources labeled the initial episodes as disastrously paced or slow to find footing.

🎯 Who This Product Is For

Reviewer recommendations for different target audiences and use cases.

✅
Fans of Dark Comedy The series is recommended for viewers who enjoy cynical, high-stakes humor mixed with family dysfunction.
8 / 16
✅
Dan Levy Fans Those who appreciate the creator's previous work will find familiar DNA here, though it is noted to be grittier and less cozy than previous projects.
5 / 16

🛠️ Best Use Cases

  • Binge-watching The series is consistently described as highly bingeable due to its fast-paced editing and cliffhanger-heavy structure. Great

🔀 Alternatives Mentioned by Reviewers

Reviewers frequently compared Big Mistakes to other shows, highlighting its specific niche in the dark comedy-crime genre.

  • Schitt’s Creek — Levy’s previous work; compared for its sibling dynamics and comedic timing, though Big Mistakes is noted to be much grittier and less warm.
  • Succession — Mentioned as a point of comparison for dysfunctional family dynamics, specifically described as a middle-class version with more heart.
  • Fargo, Ozark, and Only Murders in the Building — Referenced as superior examples of the civilian-in-crime genre, which Big Mistakes struggles to match in originality.
  • Weeds, Killing It, Deli Boys, and Sunny Nights — Cited as direct genre peers; Big Mistakes shares their DNA but lacks the organic desperation of these shows.
  • I Love LA (HBO) — Compared for its loud, ironic humor style.

Alternatives sourced exclusively from reviewer mentions.

🛒 Buyer's Guide

✅ Buy This If…

  • You prioritize strong comedic performances over narrative logic.
  • You enjoy cynical, dark, and chaotic family-based comedies.

❌ Skip This If…

  • You require a tight, logically consistent crime-thriller plot.
  • You are sensitive to loud, grating noise and chaotic tonal shifts.
⚖️ MIXED RECEPTION

Big Mistakes is a classic case of a show carried entirely by its talented cast. While Dan Levy and his co-stars deliver brilliant, biting performances, the underlying crime plot is frequently described as illogical and underdeveloped. It is an entertaining, bingeable mess that succeeds as a family comedy but falters as a thriller. If you are looking for character-driven laughs, it is a fun watch, but those seeking a cohesive crime narrative should look elsewhere.