Skip to main content

Mayday Review

Written on .

Consensus Review18 independent sources

Mayday (2026)

A Cold War-themed buddy action-comedy directed by the team behind Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves and starring Ryan Reynolds and Kenneth Branagh.

6.8/10
GENERALLY RECOMMENDED
✅ 67% Positive (12 sources)⚠️ 22% Mixed (4 sources)❌ 11% Negative (2 sources)

How This Score Is Calculated

  • Sources analysed: 18 reviews (Source 19 excluded as music album)
  • Sentiment-only: 18 sources (weighted 1.0×)
  • Split: 12 Positive · 4 Mixed · 2 Negative
  • Raw weighted average: 6.8
  • Most reviewed featureLead Chemistry (16/18)
  • Most praisedKenneth Branagh
  • Most criticisedNarrative Predictability
  • Reviewer consensus levelModerate
Generally RecommendedAction Comedy FansBuddy Movie Enthusiasts

Mayday arrives as a high-production, Apple TV-distributed action-comedy that attempts to recapture the spirit of 1980s and 90s buddy-adventure films. It positions itself as a lighthearted, retro-inspired romp, drawing heavy thematic and structural inspiration from films like Top Gun: Maverick and Midnight Run.

The film enters a crowded streaming market, relying on the star power of Ryan Reynolds and Kenneth Branagh to anchor its Cold War-era premise. Critics observe that while the film aims for the same "smart-aleck" swagger seen in the directors' previous hits, it ultimately settles for a safer, more formulaic execution.

🔧 Key Specifications

  • Stars: Ryan Reynolds, Kenneth Branagh
  • Genre: Action / Comedy / Buddy-Road Trip
  • Setting: 1987 Cold War
  • Distribution: Apple TV
  • Director: (John Francis Daley & Jonathan Goldstein)

📊 What Reviewers Say — Feature by Feature

5 features evaluated across 18 sources.

✅
Lead ChemistryThe majority of reviewers praise the dynamic interaction between Reynolds and Branagh as the film's primary anchor, though a minority find the pairing forced.
13 / 18
✅
Kenneth BranaghConsistently cited as the standout performance, with critics highlighting his eccentric and dedicated turn as a former KGB agent.
10 / 18
✅
Action SequencesAction set pieces are described as kinetically filmed and well-choreographed, even if some critics feel they rely too heavily on CGI.
11 / 18
⚠️
Ryan ReynoldsCritics are divided on his performance, with some enjoying his signature charm and others finding his repetitive smart-ass banter tiresome.
9 / 18
❌
Narrative DepthWidely criticized for being thin, formulaic, and reliant on tired Cold War stereotypes.
8 / 18

👍 Key Strengths

  • Kenneth Branagh's standout performance
  • Strong lead chemistry
  • Dynamic, well-shot action sequences
  • Lighthearted, breezy tone
  • Polished visual production

👎 Key Weaknesses

  • Formulaic and thin plot
  • Repetitive Reynolds tropes
  • Superficial character development
  • Underutilized supporting cast
  • Excessive CGI reliance

⚡ Where Reviewers Disagreed

The following areas saw meaningful disagreement across sources.

  • Lead Chemistry: 13 sources praised the rapport, while 3 sources described it as contrived or lacking. The disagreement centres on whether the duo's disparate styles create a fun "odd couple" dynamic or a mismatched, forced pairing. No consistent explanation for the split was evident across sources.

🎯 Who This Product Is For

Reviewer recommendations for different target audiences.

✅
Action-Comedy FansThose seeking a breezy, lighthearted film with solid action and charismatic leads will find it highly watchable.
12 / 18
✅
80s/90s Nostalgia SeekersViewers who enjoy the tropes of classic buddy-road trip movies will appreciate the film's self-aware homage to the genre.
9 / 18
❌
Fans of OriginalityViewers looking for a ground-breaking narrative or sharp, witty social commentary may find the film too safe and formulaic.
6 / 18

🔀 Alternatives Mentioned by Reviewers

  • Midnight Run — Frequently cited as the gold standard for the buddy-road trip genre, it is recommended for those wanting a sharper, more character-driven comedy.
  • Top Gun: Maverick — Referenced by multiple critics as the inspiration for the film's flight sequences and "behind enemy lines" survival themes.
  • Game Night — The directors' previous film, suggested for those who prefer more acidic wit and original narrative stakes over the safer approach taken here.
  • Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves — Also from the same directors, this film is compared to Mayday for its similar board-game-style adventure tone, though reviewers generally find it more engaging.
  • Lethal Weapon — Used as a reference point for the classic 80s buddy-cop dynamic that Mayday attempts to emulate.

Alternatives sourced exclusively from reviewer mentions.

✅ Buy This If…

  • You enjoy lighthearted buddy-comedy dynamics and charismatic lead performances.
  • You are looking for a visually polished, easy-to-watch action movie for a casual evening.
  • You appreciate 80s action movie homages and solid, kinetic stunts.

❌ Skip This If…

  • You are looking for deep character development or a highly original script.
  • You are tired of Ryan Reynolds' signature brand of sarcastic banter.
  • You prefer historically credible or gritty, serious Cold War dramas.
👍GENERALLY RECOMMENDED

Mayday is a breezy, self-aware buddy-comedy that succeeds primarily on the strength of Kenneth Branagh’s standout performance and his chemistry with Ryan Reynolds. While the narrative is undeniably formulaic and leans heavily on tired Cold War tropes, the film remains an entertaining, visually polished escapade for those who enjoy the classic 80s buddy-road trip genre. It falls short of the sharper wit found in the directors' previous works, but functions effectively as a fun, lighthearted watch. If you enjoy the genre, it is a solid recommendation, though it may feel repetitive for those fatigued by Reynolds' typical persona.